Thursday, December 28, 2023

Abrasive Jet Machining (AJM)

 In abrasive jet machining process, a focused steam of abrasive particles (of size 10 to 40 microns) carried by high pressure gas or air at a velocity of about 150 to 300 m/sec is made to impinge on the work surface through a nozzle, and the work material is removed by erosion by the high velocity abrasive particles. The inside diameter (ID) of the nozzle through which abrasive particles flow is about 0.18 to 0.80 mm and the stand-off distance (i.e. distance between nozzle tip and workpiece) is kept about 0.3 to 20.0 mm. The process can be easily controlled to vary the metal removal rate which depends on flow rate and size of abrasive particles. This process is best suited for machining super alloys and refractory type of materials, and also machining thin sections of hard materials and making intricate hard holes. The cutting action is cool because the carrier gas serves as coolant. 


When an abrasive particle (like Al2O3 or SiC) having sharp edges hits a brittle and fragile material with a high speed, it makes dent into the material and lodges a small particle from it by a tiny brittle fracture. The lodged out or wear particle is carried away by the air or gas. The operating elements in AJM are abrasive, carrier gas and the nozzle as schematically shown in the following Figure

Abrasive Jet Machining (AJM) Principles
Abrasive Jet Machining (AJM) Principles 


The distance between the nozzle tip and the work surface has great influence on the diameter of cut, its shape and size and also rate of material removal. The following Figure shows the variation in the diameter of cut with change in the stand off distance (SOD). It is evident that the SOD changes the abrasive particles spreads (i.e. covers wider area) on the work surface and consequently increases the diameter of the cut.
change in the stand off distance (SOD) in AJM

The basic Units of AJM



The basic unit is schematically shown in following Figure. It consists of gas supply system (compressor), filter, pressure regulator, mixing chamber, nozzle assembly and the work holding device. In the mixing chamber, the abrasive is allowed to flow into the gas stream. The mixing ratio is generally controlled by a vibrator. The particle and gas mixture comes out of the nozzle inside the machining chamber of the machine tool unit. The feed motion can be given either to the work holding device or to the nozzle. 
basic units of abrasive jet machining (AJM)
AJM setup

Abrasive Jet Machining (AJM) Advantages:

  • This process is quite suitable for machining brittle, heat resistant and fragile materials like, glass, ceramic, germanium, mica etc. 
  • It can be utilized for cutting, drilling, polishing, deburring, cleaning etc. of the materials. 
  • The depth of damage to the surface is very little. 
  • Holes of intricate shapes could be produced efficiently.
  • The surface machined can have good finish (by controlling the grain size mainly). 

AJM Disadvantages: 


The materials removal rate is low. For example, for glass, it is 0.0164 cm3/min. 
  • The tapering of hole especially, when the depth of the hole is more, becomes almost inevitable. 
  • A dust collecting chamber is a basic requirement to prevent atmospheric pollution to cause health hazards.
  • The abrasive particles may remain embedded in the work surface. 
  • Abrasive particles cannot be reused.

AJM Applications:

  • Abrasive jet machining is best suited for machining brittle and heat sensitive materials like glass, quartz, sapphire, ceramics etc,
  • It is used for drilling holes, cutting slots, cleaning hard surfaces, deburring, polishing etc. 

Water Jet Machining (WJM)

  In Water jet Machining no abrasive is used. Water jet alone is used for cutting. In WJM, materials like concrete, asbestos, wood, rocks, coal, textiles and leather can be cut. The material is removed by means of erosion. These days hydraulic coal mining as well as tunneling, descaling and cleaning is also done by this process. 



        Water Jet Machining (WJM) Principles 


As the name suggests the water jet machining process involves the use of high velocity  and high pressure thin jets of water to cut the job. Water Jet is the stream of high velocity water coming out from the nozzle. When high pressure water jet comes out of the nozzle it gains a large kinetic energy. After striking the work piece this kinetic energy is converted to pressure energy inducing high stress on the material. When this induced stress surpasses the ultimate stress of the material, removal starts

         Schematic Diagram of WJM 


        The schematic diagram of  WJM process is very similar to that for AJM. To raise the pressure of the water a pump or intensifier is used. The system pressure ranges from 1600 to 4000 N/mm2. The accumulator used in the system act as a pulsation remover and an energy reservoir. Water passes through the accumulator and then nozzle through a high pressure thick tube. The tube material may be stainless steel jacketed with carbon steel. Sintered diamond , sapphire or tungsten carbide may be used as the nozzle material. The exit dia. of the nozzle may vary from 0.05 to 0.35 mm. 



Water Jet Machining (WJM) Advantages and Disadvantages
a. Schematic of Water Jet Machining b. Example of workpiece machined by WJM


Advantages of Water Jet Machining Process 

1. Here water is used for cutting which is cheap, non-toxic and readily available. 
2. The water jet keeps the job clean and dust free. 
3. The only moving part used is the pump, therefore the operating and
maintenance expenses are low. 
4. The process is very safe to use. 
5. Very complicated designs and detailed work can be done. 
6. There is no damage of the workpiece due to thermal stress. Very little heat is
generated. 
7. Soft rubber like materials can be cut through this process where saw teeth
gets clogged
          

Disadvantages of WJM.

1. Hard Materials cannot be cut. 
2. The initial cost is high. 

Applications:

1. Cutting 
2. Milling 
3. 3D Shaping
4. Turning
5. Piercing
6. Drilling
7. Polishing 

Electrical Discharge Machining (EDM) Principles

EDM is a non-conventional machining technique uniquely used for cutting metals which are not possible to cut with traditional methods. EDM only works with materials which are electrically conductive. Delicate cavities and intricate contours which are difficult to produce with a grinder or other machines can be done with Electrical Discharge Machining or EDM. The cutting tool for EDM may be made of hardened too steel, titanium carbide or inconel or kovar.  

EDM is also known as "Spark Machining" . Such name has been given for the fact that it removes the metal by applying a rapid series of repetitive electrical discharges. An electrode and the work piece is used for the conducting path of these electrical discharges. A continuously flowing fluid is always flowing to flush away the little amount of material that are removed. Repetitive discharge gives the workpiece a desired shape.

Two primary EDM methods are

Ram EDM and
Wire EDM.

Between this two methods the main difference is found in the electrodes. In ram EDM graphite electrodes are used. These electrodes are machined in traditional tools and a special shape is given which is connected to the power source. The electrodes are also connected to a ram. When all the arrangements are ready the electrodes are fed into the workpiece. The entire process is performed under a submerged fluid bath. In Wire EDM the electrode it self is a thin wire. Specially processed brass wires are used for feeding into the material. Electrical discharges cut the w/p according to desired shape. Wire EDM is generally done while submerged in a bath of water.

Ram Electro-Discharge Machining (EDM) Process

Rapid recurrence of spark produced between the two electrodes (tool & w/p) controls the metal erosion. It is to be noted that the workpiece must be an electrically conducting metal. An appropriate gap is necessary which is usually approximately 0.025 to 0.075 mm known as spark gap. The gap must be maintained between the w/p and the tool by a servo motor which runs by the difference between a reference and gap breakdown voltage. The tool moves upwards and downwards by this operating motor.
The rate of metal removal depends on the spark gap. If both the electrodes are made of same materials then the highest erosion is found on the positive electrode or the anode. So logically to get a high metal removal rate and a greater tool life the tool is made as cathode and workpiece works as anode, The two electrodes are kept apart and are separated by a dielectric fluid. A transient electric discharge is found across the gap between the two electrodes in the form of spark. When the potential difference between the electrodes is sufficient, the dielectric fluid is ionized and break down which in terms produces an conductive spark channel. The current is discharged across the channel by the condensers as spark. If the potential difference is less than or equal to 12 volts the dielectric fluid is deionized. The process is repeat itself as the condensers start to recharge. The spark interval is generally 10 to 30 microseconds and the current density ranges from 15-500 am/mm2. The energy is released from the sparks in the form of local heat and eventually local temperature found is in the order of 12000°C. Such high temperature and pressure melts and erodes some metals some of which is vaporized and other fine material particles are carried by the fluid circulating around the electrodes which creates a crater on the w/p. As the time interval of the sparks is very low the heat doesn't get time to conducted between the tool & workpiece. Fig below shows a schematic diagram of the whole process.

RAM Electrical Discharge Machining (EDM)



How to choose the Tool Material
Many factors are needed to be taken into consideration while selecting the tool material.

  • Low erosion rate and decent work to tool wear ratio
  • good electrical conductivity 
  • good machinability 
  • low electrical resistance 
  • high melting point . 
  • high rate of electron emission  
EDM has one major drawback and it is the wear ratio of the tool. Different material has different wear ratio. For Brass it is 1:1 . For metallic electrodes it is found 3:1 or 4:1 . For high melting point electrode graphite it ranges from 5:1 to 50 :1 . 


Tool Wear

While applying EDM the tool or cathode also erodes which is not desirable. It is unavoidable but remains in tolerable limit as the wear of the cathode is much less than the anode. This occurs because -

  • Positive ions from the dielectric fluid hit the cathode but electrons strikes the anode. Though electrons are much lighter than the positive ions it possesses more energy as it moves it greater velocity. So anode gets more eroded. 
  • At the time of spark a compressive force is created at the cathode which reduces the cathode erosion. 
  • Fluid medium is generally hydrocarbon. Due to pyrolysis gases are produced which produces carbon particle and these particles create a thin layer of protection on the cathode. Thus the cathode is much safer than anode. 


Purpose of Dielectric Fluid 

  • Effective Coolant for the workpiece and the tool . 
  • It works as an insulating material during the charging of the condenser as a result perfect condition for efficacious spark discharge and its conduction when ionized is obtained. 
  • The eroded materials are carried away by this medium. 
  • It is a coolant in quenching the spark and prevents the arcing. 

Essential Requirements for dielectric fluid 

  • Optimum Viscosity is necessary . If the viscosity is low then the fluid will not be able to carry the metal particles. On the other hand if the viscosity is high then it will restrict the flow of the liquid. 
  • It should be non-reactive with the work piece, container or the tool material. 
  • Non-expensive, easily available and inflammable. 
  • It should not produce toxic gases or vapors during the operation. 
  • It should be a hydrocarbon compound. 
Different dielectric fluids are : transformer oil, spirit (white), oil and kerosene etc. If some conducting power like aluminum or light graphite is added to the fluid then the metal removal rate increases. 



Advantages of EDM

  • Metal having any hardness or brittleness and toughness can be machined. 
  • Harder materials such as steel alloys or tungsten carbides which are used for molding and other non-conventional machining like forging and press tools can be reproduced. 
  • Dies can be machined at hardened condition. 
  • Complicated shapes can be reproduced. 
  • Very fine holes can be done very accurately . 
  • The accuracy is very high. Tolerance of 0.005 mm can be achieved. 
  • Wear resistance surface can be made because workpieces produced with EDM have micro-craters which can contain lubricants effectively. 
  • The physical contact between the tool and w/p is avoided. No cutting force other than blasting pressure is exerted. So fragile jobs and cylinders can be machined without causing any damage. 
  • Harder metals can be machined very quickly in comparison to the conventional machining process. 


Disadvantages Electrical Discharge Machining 

  • The power required for machining is much higher compared to the conventional machining. (120J/mm2)
  • There are chances of surface cracking when the materials become brittle at room temperature. 
  • A thin layer usually ranging from 0.01 mm to 0,10 mm containing 4 % carbon may be deposited on the workpieces made of steel 
  • The Material Removal Rate  (MRR) is comparatively low (75 mm3/sec)
  • Reproducing sharp corners is difficult in EDM. 
  • Sometimes the micro-structures are distorted and subsequently etching occurs. 



Applications of EDM 

Generally EDM is hugely used for machining burr free intricate shapes as well as narrow slots and blind cavities. Sinking of dies , plastic molding, die casting compacting, cold heading, extrusion, press tools, wire drawings are some of the examples of its application. Negative tool geometry can also be generated on a w/p if suitable tool can be made. EDM is very useful for machining small holes. It is also used to cut slot in diesel fuel injection nozzles. It is also used in air crfat engines and brake valves etc.


Wire Electrical Discharge Machining

A very thin wire of diameter ranging from 0.02 to 0.3 mm is used as an electrode in wire cut EDM. It cuts the workpiece with electrical discharge just like a band saw. In this process either workpiece or the wire is moved. The spark discharge phenomenon is used for eroding the metal which is same as the conventional EDM. In wire cut EDM the wire acts as an electrode as a result complicated shapes can be cut easily without forming electrode. Basically the wire-cut EDM consists of a machine which has a workpiece contour movement control unit ( NC tension : a power supply which supplies electrical energy to the wire and has a unit ) . It also has workpiece mounting table and a wire driver section. The wire driver section is use for moving the wire accurately at a constant tension. Another important part is the dielectric fluid (distilled water) supplier having constant specific resistance. Wire EDM has the following features -   
  •  No forming electrode is necessary. 
  • electrode wear is very negligible. 
  • Smooth machined surface. 
  • Tight geometrical and dimensional tolerances . 
  • Extremely high tolerances between punch and die. Extended die life. 
  • Straight holes are possible to produce. 
  • Machine can be operated without any regular supervision for long time at high operating rates. 
  • No skill is needed to run the machine. 
Wire Cut EDM


Advantages

  • Because of the absense of the split lines in the die, savings of the stages in the sequential tools occurs. It permits more punch opening per stage. 
  • There will no flashes on the molded parts because the molds with draught  can be arranged without vertical divisions. 
  • To necessity for tool manufacturing and storing. 
  •  Workpieces are hardened before cutting . So no heat treatment distortion is not present. 
  • Whole work is done in one machine . So die manufacturing cycle time is short. 
  • Lesser inspection time because of single piece construction of dies with high accuracy. 
  • Time is utilized perfectly as the wire cut EDM can cut throughout the day. 
  • Very economical even for small batch production. 
  • low thermally affected zone. High surface finish. 
  • Number of rejected workpieces are very small.